Jump to content

South Of Sheffield Traffic Madness


Recommended Posts

14 hours ago, Justin Smith said:

I remain unconvinced that if public transport was really free that substantial numbers of car drivers would fail to use it.

 

My own research indicates that just a 10 to 20% drop in car use would result in a significant reduction in traffic jams.

 

Many commentators put the reduction in peak hour traffic during the school summer holidays as being perhaps a quarter to a third. I think most people would view the difference at that time as being "substantial".

 

I'd think a 10% reduction might make a bit of difference, you'd probably notice it, but it wouldn't' be huge.

 

There are some interesting articles about the impact of free public transport. This one reckons that car use decreased by 10% in Aubagne in France (Population 100k).

 

Apparently Hassfelt in Belgium had free public transport for a good number of years but had to start charging as it was no longer economically viable.

 

In this article, researchers from Delft university looked into the impact of the free public transport scheme in Tallin and found the number of people swapping from car use to public transport was 8%, but average length of car trips went up by 31% and there were more cars on the road (perhaps due to changes in shopping and leisure habits). Interestingly the researchers thought that making motoring more expensive, such as by increased parking fees, might be more effective in reducing car trips. They also found "mixed evidence" on whether the scheme had improved mobility and accessibility of low income and unemployed residents and no evidence that employment opportunities increased as a result of the policy (so it didn't attract new jobs to the area). They concluded that free public transport wasn't the "no brainer" that everyone might initially think it to be.  

Edited by Planner1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

14 hours ago, Justin Smith said:

However, just making parking more expensive and/or reducing its availability is a very dangerous game to play as many car owners simply change their behaviour and, for example, shop in out of town centres with free parking. We see this all around us, city / town centre shops closing yet out of town centres are packed. 

most commentators have the view that whether or not people come to a particular town / city / district to shop is more dependant on the overall "offer" of the place rather than the cost of parking.

 

The decline in town centre retail is mostly put down to changes in the way we shop and spend our leisure time, not parking charges.

 

Retailers sometimes have a skewed view about parking charges, because they incorrectly think the majority of customers come to them by car.

 

If you ask a typical retailer (in a town or district shopping area) they will say maybe 60% of customers come to them by car, and 40% by public transport or other means. The reality is absolutely the opposite as shown in this Sustrans study, which I had replicated in a South Yorkshire town when I worked there and got very much the same result.

 

This research suggested that over a period of a month, people who walked and cycled actually spent more in shops than car drivers (who spent more per visit, but visited less).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I would be surprised if many people walk or cycle into the city to do their shopping (not town or district but city as in Sheffield) but can appriciate people living local to an out of town shopping area doing so. It all depends on the type of shops and the type of shopping required. It is easy to pop to a local shop for a loaf/pint of milk but don't expect anyone to walk or cycle a couple of miles to do the weekly shopping and then have to carry it home. Yes i know it is posible to shop on line but not everyone wants/can do this and stuff can be delivered but usuall at a cost.

 

When permission to build these shopping centres is sought more care and study should go into the infrastructure arround them prior to granting permission to build. 

 

I believe the decline in shopping in Sheffield city centre is due to ease of access close enough to the main shopping areas by car or public transport (as above ...people carrying bags etc) and the change of housing over the years. A great proportion of the population moved away from the city centre to "the suberbs" and district shopping areas then becamr more conveniant, especially when ample parking is available. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Planner1 said:

Many commentators put the reduction in peak hour traffic during the school summer holidays as being perhaps a quarter to a third. I think most people would view the difference at that time as being "substantial".

 

I'd think a 10% reduction might make a bit of difference, you'd probably notice it, but it wouldn't' be huge.

 

There are some interesting articles about the impact of free public transport. This one reckons that car use decreased by 10% in Aubagne in France (Population 100k).

 

Apparently Hassfelt in Belgium had free public transport for a good number of years but had to start charging as it was no longer economically viable.

 

In this article, researchers from Delft university looked into the impact of the free public transport scheme in Tallin and found the number of people swapping from car use to public transport was 8%, but average length of car trips went up by 31% and there were more cars on the road (perhaps due to changes in shopping and leisure habits). Interestingly the researchers thought that making motoring more expensive, such as by increased parking fees, might be more effective in reducing car trips. They also found "mixed evidence" on whether the scheme had improved mobility and accessibility of low income and unemployed residents and no evidence that employment opportunities increased as a result of the policy (so it didn't attract new jobs to the area). They concluded that free public transport wasn't the "no brainer" that everyone might initially think it to be.  

Aren't all those tests fairly small conurbations ?

I can remember distinctly when Sth Yorks cheap bus fares were abolished and the traffic became significantly worse almost overnight. And that was just cheap fares, not free.

58 minutes ago, Planner1 said:

most commentators have the view that whether or not people come to a particular town / city / district to shop is more dependant on the overall "offer" of the place rather than the cost of parking.

 

The decline in town centre retail is mostly put down to changes in the way we shop and spend our leisure time, not parking charges.

 

Retailers sometimes have a skewed view about parking charges, because they incorrectly think the majority of customers come to them by car.

 

If you ask a typical retailer (in a town or district shopping area) they will say maybe 60% of customers come to them by car, and 40% by public transport or other means. The reality is absolutely the opposite as shown in this Sustrans study, which I had replicated in a South Yorkshire town when I worked there and got very much the same result.

 

This research suggested that over a period of a month, people who walked and cycled actually spent more in shops than car drivers (who spent more per visit, but visited less).

I would very much dispute that the cost of parking has minimal effect on whether people use their car to access a particular area, though I'd agree that the absence of parking has an even bigger effect.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Meltman said:

When permission to build these shopping centres is sought more care and study should go into the infrastructure arround them prior to granting permission to build.

An irony here for me is the amount of thought that was supposed to have been put in to the St James Retail traffic flows - and it is still an idiotic road layout

 

My mother in law lives opposite and, along with many of her neighbours, they campaigned to have decent access - because they feared everyone would park on their road to walk in. Which lots now do, clogging quiet residential streets

 

Personally avoid driving when I can, but public transport in Sheffield is, in my experience, pretty dire. Easily 90 mins each way to travel 6 miles by bus. Can do the same trip by e-bike in 20 - 30 minutes or so, but too few decent cycle routes and too many near misses

 

Used to work in Manchester. The commute by train was about an hour but £150 a week to stand both ways - generally quicker than moving a handful of miles around Sheffield though

Edited by HappyCampers
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Meltman said:

I would be surprised if many people walk or cycle into the city to do their shopping (not town or district but city as in Sheffield) but can appriciate people living local to an out of town shopping area doing so. It all depends on the type of shops and the type of shopping required. It is easy to pop to a local shop for a loaf/pint of milk but don't expect anyone to walk or cycle a couple of miles to do the weekly shopping and then have to carry it home. Yes i know it is posible to shop on line but not everyone wants/can do this and stuff can be delivered but usuall at a cost.

 

When permission to build these shopping centres is sought more care and study should go into the infrastructure arround them prior to granting permission to build. 

 

I believe the decline in shopping in Sheffield city centre is due to ease of access close enough to the main shopping areas by car or public transport (as above ...people carrying bags etc) and the change of housing over the years. A great proportion of the population moved away from the city centre to "the suberbs" and district shopping areas then becamr more conveniant, especially when ample parking is available. 

How close do you want to be able to park next to city centre shops? I can park on top of John Lewis or Atkinsons, in the car park bang next to the Moor, in the Cheesegrater on Peace Gardens, on street and off street parking on Division St, and many many more I could list. Public transport runs directly through the centre of town.

 

It couldn't be easier.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Bargepole23 said:

How close do you want to be able to park next to city centre shops? I can park on top of John Lewis or Atkinsons, in the car park bang next to the Moor, in the Cheesegrater on Peace Gardens, on street and off street parking on Division St, and many many more I could list. Public transport runs directly through the centre of town.

 

It couldn't be easier.

...and Meadowhall is free parking and under cover. Bit of a no-brainer for most shopping TBH.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

22 minutes ago, Weredoomed said:

...and Meadowhall is free parking and under cover. Bit of a no-brainer for most shopping TBH.

Never go. I like to leave open the possibility of a nice drink or meal or both in a nice cafe/bar if I go into town. Those options are unavailable at Meadowhall.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Bargepole23 said:

How close do you want to be able to park next to city centre shops? I can park on top of John Lewis or Atkinsons, in the car park bang next to the Moor, in the Cheesegrater on Peace Gardens, on street and off street parking on Division St, and many many more I could list. Public transport runs directly through the centre of town.

 

It couldn't be easier.

My mistake...in the bit you highlighted I missed out the word LACK....meaning lack of ease of accesss etc.

We can all park at John Lewis or Atkinsons, car park, near the moor, the Cheesegrater or anywhere else available but as my post was intended it is the lack of easy access to many of these places to shop compared to the out of town shopping areas. 

It also depends on where you are coming from and availability of public transport.

If anyone wants to go into town for a social visit rather than "shopping" then I agree there are other ways to get there

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.