Census may have overestimated number of trans people in England and Wales

[The_DADDY]

The number of transgender people living in the UK may have been overestimated by the 2021 census, the Office for National Statistics (ONS) has confirmed.

Following the survey in England and Wales, it was reported that around one in 200 people aged over 16 self-identified as a different gender to their sex at birth.

However, a review found that people who do not speak fluent English may have misunderstood the wording of the relevant question and mistakenly answered that they consider themselves to be trans.

The ONS had previously defended its methodology, despite some academics raising concerns over its accuracy.

People who filled out the 2021 census in England and Wales were asked: "Is the gender you identify with the same as your sex registered at birth?"

According to the ONS, 262,000 people - around 0.5% of the population - answered "no".

But on Wednesday, Mary Gregory - a deputy director at the ONS - said some people may have misunderstood the question.

Writing on the ONS's website, she said there was "potential bias" in how the question was answered "by those who responded that they had lower levels of English proficiency, some of whom may have mistakenly given an answer suggesting they were trans".

The number of people who answered the question mistakenly is thought to be "relatively small", she added, but enough to paint an inaccurate picture in areas "where there are higher levels of non-English speakers".

Michael Biggs, a professor of sociology at Oxford University, publicly questioned the statistics in April.

NHS sets out 'safer' child gender services model

Census data reveals LGBT+ populations for first time

Judge orders change to census sex question guidance

Writing in the British Sociological Society journal, he noted a surprisingly high proportion of people recorded as identifying as trans did not speak English (or Welsh in Wales) as a first language.

While only 10% of people said they did not speak English as their main language on the census, it appeared they made up 29% of the total number of transgender people, Prof Biggs said.

For example, the London Borough of Newham had the highest proportion of people who identified as transgender (1.51%). The area also has one of the highest rates of non-English speakers - 35%, compared to 9% nationally.

The Office for Statistics Regulation has downgraded the data from "accredited official statistics" to "official statistics in development" to reflect the possible flaws.

The regulator said other statistics produced by the 2021 census are still considered to be fully accurate.

The ONS had previously said its estimates on the transgender population were in line with “international comparators”.

 

Your thoughts?

 

https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c3030519849o

[cressida]

I'm happy to be a girl as on my birth certificate - can't say I'm interested in other's predilctions or what they call themselves

[Al Bundy]

Why would they ask a question of people who don't speak English?

 

How silly.

[lavery549@yahoo]

Only in this day & age , do we find this happening . I despair , I really do 

[HeHasRisen]

5 hours ago, Al Bundy said:

Why would they ask a question of people who don't speak English?

 

How silly.

Because its a census and its useful information to collect?

[ECCOnoob]

4 hours ago, lavery549@yahoo said:

Only in this day & age , do we find this happening . I despair , I really do 

 

What the hell are you talking about?   

 

Just how many census questions do you think might have been misinterpreted or misunderstood back in the day.

 

If it wasn't for the "trans" angle, which seems to be catnip to journalists (and certain people on this very forum) looking to make a meal out of something - this shouldn't even be a discussion point. 

 

What exactly is the big story here. They found some potential anomaly in the collected data.  They have corrected it and redefined the wording in their results summary.  End of story.  

[leviathan13]

Yeah... by about 100%.

 

There's no such thing - just people with mental health issues that are being pandered to rather than actually helped.

[Slighty batty]

1 hour ago, ECCOnoob said:

 

What the hell are you talking about?   

 

Just how many census questions do you think might have been misinterpreted or misunderstood back in the day.

 

 

When they were filling in the 1911 census form, my nan’s sister asked how old she had to be to qualify as a female 

[cressida]

1 hour ago, leviathan13 said:

Yeah... by about 100%.

 

There's no such thing - just people with mental health issues that are being pandered to rather than actually helped.

Do you believe aside from mental health issues that they are deluded then instead?

[Mister M]

Oh dear, this is terrible news....

If there are fewer trans people than once thought, who are we going to moan about and blame for all the ills in society?